The Swamp Group

The Swamp Group
Panel # 1

Thursday, August 6, 2015

The Family Map (Part 1)


Above is a map of family functionality[i]
The map has two axes
The vertical axis measures authority
The horizontal axis measures closeness
The inner circle defines the boundaries of healthy functioning
The outer circle defines the unhealthy boundaries of severe malfunction
At each corner of the map is a brief description of families with particular combinations of unhealthy features
The vertical authority axis is a means of measuring the authority component of a family’s structure
First let’s look at Chaos
·        Chaos is at the top of this map
o   this positioning is arbitrary
o   it could have just as well been at the bottom
o   Chaos just needs to be at the map’s extreme edge where dysfunction belongs
·        Chaos is a total lack of structure and a total lack of authority
·         Chaos happens when family members and in particular the head(s) of the household lose authority, when they experience complete loss of control
o   For instance a drunken father might lose his authority while he is intoxicated
·        Chaos also results from a complete lack of structure
o   A household where bills may or may not be paid, where chores go undone, without mealtimes, where schedules are absent or ignored
Next let’s look at Rigid
·        Rigid is the opposite of Chaos so it’s at the bottom of the map
·        Although it’s opposite of Chaos it’s no better
o   It is just as bad but in the opposite way
·        Rigid is a total lack of any flexibility and any negotiability with authority
·        Rigid happens when family members particularly the head(s) of the household are unyielding, unforgiving, unapproachable and inhumane
o   Many instances of child abuse are the result of inhumane disciplinary practices
·        Rigid happens when rules proliferate beyond reason, when rules are often unwritten and contradictory
o   In other words when no matter what you do you are probably violating some sort of rule and likely to “catch hell” for breaking a rule
·        Rigid households are emotionally paralyzing they are paralyzed with structure
o   You may feel like you need permission just to breathe in these families
Now we shift from vertical to horizontal



The horizontal intimacy axis is a means of measuring the interpersonal relationships in a family’s structure
First let’s look at Enmeshed
·        The placement of Enmeshed to the right and Disengaged to the left is arbitrary
·        Enmeshed means a lack of appropriate interpersonal boundaries
o   An extreme example of enmeshment would be incest
o   Enmeshment can be present without going to this extreme
·        Every family member has an appropriate role to play in the family
o   There are parental roles for the parents to play
o   There are various roles for children which may vary according to age and ability (babies play baby roles, teenagers play teenage roles)
·        When roles become unclear and confused this is enmeshment
o   For instance a mother and a daughter sharing a double date violates important boundaries between parent and child
·        So called role reversal where an adult child cares for his or her parent is not generally a violation of boundaries
o   Caring for a person can be a way of honoring them
o   If there is a history of boundary violations such care may be problematic
·        Enmeshed families tend to have many secrets
·        Enmeshed families may feel like a trap or prison
·        Enmeshed families may lack any personal privacy
Now let’s look at Disengaged
·        Disengaged is the opposite of Enmeshed but it is no better
·        Disengaged means lack of connection
o   An extreme example would be abandonment of a newborn baby
o   Disengagement can occur without being this extreme
·        When family members particularly parents abandon their appropriate roles Disengagement is the result
o   For instance if a parent repeatedly fails to attend his (or her) child’s recital or game or other significant event the child may feel unloved by or disconnected from the parent (they feel abandoned)
·        Disengaged families lack traditions and rituals
·        In disengaged families the family members may completely ignore each other
·        Disengaged families do not show genuine care or concern for family members
·        As adults members may lose track of each other




[i] This map is used with the permission of Patrick Carnes PhD. 

No comments:

Post a Comment